Hotels in Sag Harbor, New York
The hotels in Sag Harbor are located near several prominent local landmarks. Both listings sit close to cultural sites such as the Custom House, the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, and The Church Sag Harbor. Guests can also find themselves near natural attractions, with Windmill Beach, Havens Beach, Short Beach, and Foster Memorial Bathing Beach all nearby. Additionally, the listings are convenient to the Sag Harbor Fireman's Museum, the Ice House (ruins), and John Steinbeck Waterfront Park.
The available stock consists entirely of hotels. Each of the two listings offers a guest rating, with scores ranging from 4.25 to 4.7. Both properties provide amenities such as a pool, breakfast, parking, and beach access.
Both listed properties quote a starting rate. The cheapest room at any property begins at $405, and the highest starting rate found is $735. These rates are for the most affordable rooms at each location. Every hotel page presents rooms, photos, and current rates.
Sag Harbor hotels at a glance
| Hotel | Guest rating | Reviews | From | Known for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sag Harbor Inn | 4.7/5 | 653 | from $405 | Breakfast |
| Faraway Sag Harbor | 4.25/5 | 109 | from $735 | Breakfast |
Where to stay in Sag Harbor
West Water Street
West Water Street has multiple listings in Sag Harbor. Properties on this street are near the Custom House and the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum. This area suits visitors interested in historic sites and museums.
Nearby areas
Good to know
How many places to stay are listed in Sag Harbor?
2 independently-run properties are listed in Sag Harbor, New York, with rooms, photos and live partner rates on each page.
What do hotels in Sag Harbor cost?
Listed nightly rates on partner sites start around $405 and run to about $735 depending on the property, room and dates. Rates are indicative — the live price shows on the booking partner's page.
Which hotel in Sag Harbor do guests rate highest?
Sag Harbor Inn, rated 4.7/5 from 653 Google reviews.
What amenities are available at hotels in Sag Harbor?
All two listed hotels offer a pool, breakfast, parking, and beach access. This ensures that guests have options for recreation, dining, transportation, and direct access to coastal areas during their stay.
Which cultural landmarks are near the listed hotels in Sag Harbor?
Both hotels are near several cultural landmarks, including the Custom House, the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, The Church Sag Harbor, and the Sag Harbor Fireman's Museum. Guests can easily visit these sites to explore local history and art.