The Sag Harbor Inn is a fully renovated 42-room luxury boutique hotel situated in Sag Harbor, New York. It overlooks the harbor, offering panoramic views. Located on West Water Street, the hotel is within walking distance of Main Street's boutiques, dining, museums, and galleries, making it suitable for leisure and corporate guests.
Should you book Sag Harbor Inn?
A renovated boutique hotel with harbor views, convenient to Sag Harbor's attractions.
Best for
- Walkable access to Sag Harbor
- Harbor views
- Relaxing by the pool
Maybe not ideal for
- No on-site restaurant or bar
- Rooms can be small
Harbor views
The hotel offers panoramic views of Sag Harbor's bay, with colorful sails and beaches visible from many vantage points. Enjoy the scenery from the terrace or balcony.
Renovated rooms
All 42 rooms have been renovated and feature air-conditioning, private bathrooms, work desks, TVs, and free toiletries. Some rooms include balconies or patios.
Seasonal pool
A seasonal outdoor swimming pool is available for guests. The area around the pool offers outdoor seating and is suitable for events.
Central location
Situated in the heart of the Hamptons, the inn is within walking distance of Sag Harbor's historic Main Street, including boutiques, dining, and cultural sites.
Rooms & rates
1st floor Poolside Queen Bed
36.0 m² · 1 queen bed
Pool view · Air conditioning · Patio · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
1st floor Poolside 2 Double Beds
36.0 m² · 2 full beds
Pool view · Air conditioning · Patio · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
1st floor Harbor 2 Double Beds
36.0 m² · 2 full beds
View · Air conditioning · Patio · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
2nd floor Poolside Queen Bed
36.0 m² · 1 queen bed
Balcony · Pool view · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Terrace
2nd floor Poolside 2 Double Beds
36.0 m² · 2 full beds
Balcony · Pool view · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Terrace
2nd floor Harbor 2 Double Beds
36.0 m² · 2 full beds
Balcony · View · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Terrace
What you'll enjoy
Gallery
Amenities & facilities
Most popular facilities
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Non-smoking rooms
- Free parking
- Free Wifi
- Good Breakfast
Great for your stay
- Parking
- Private bathroom
- Air conditioning
- Bath
- Free Wifi
- Free parking
- Non-smoking rooms
- Flat-screen TV
Private bathroom
- Toilet paper
- Towels
- Bath or shower
- Toilet
- Free toiletries
- Hairdryer
- Bath
Bedroom
- Linens
Outdoors
- Outdoor furniture
Kitchen
- Cleaning products
- Refrigerator
Location
45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States, Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor Inn is located in Sag Harbor, New York.
5 sights nearby; the nearest beach, Windmill Beach, is 0.3 mi away.
Things to do nearby
- Sag Harbor Whaling Museummuseum0.3 mi
- First Presbyterian Churchplace of worship0.5 mi
- Temple Adas Israelplace of worship0.7 mi
- Mashashimuet Parkpark0.8 mi
- Short Beachbeach1.1 mi
Straight-line distances from the property · data © OpenStreetMap contributors
What guests say
8.7 / 10 · Very good on Booking.com, from 154 guest reviews
The Sag Harbor Inn earns consistently warm reviews for its prime waterfront location, walkability to Main Street, attentive staff, and well-maintained, spacious rooms — with thoughtful touches like anniversary surprises highlighting the personal service. The main gripes centre on peak-season pricing that some find hard to justify, a pool that was closed or dated for several guests, and a continental breakfast that divides opinion between adequate and uninspiring.
Reviews scoring 9–10: 21 · average 9.7
They wrote about: location, room, staff
Reviews scoring 7–9: 9 · average 8
They wrote about: location, room, staff
No reviews in the selected score range.
Good to know
House rules
- Check-in
From 3:00 PM to 12:00 AM
Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card at check-in.
- Check-out
From 5:00 AM to 11:00 AM
- Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Enter your stay dates and check the conditions of your selected option.
- Age restriction
The minimum age for check-in is 21
- Pets
Pets are not allowed.
Frequently asked questions
What amenities are in the rooms?
Rooms feature air-conditioning, private bathrooms, work desks, TVs, free toiletries, free WiFi, and refrigerators. Some rooms also have patios or balconies.
Is parking available?
Yes, the hotel offers free on-site private parking for guests, including accessible parking.
Does the hotel have a restaurant?
The Sag Harbor Inn does not have an on-site restaurant, but several dining options like The Corner Bar and Il Capuccino Ristorante are within walking distance.
Is breakfast included?
The hotel is noted for having 'Good Breakfast', and it is typically included with room bookings.
What room types are available?
Room types include 1st floor Poolside (1 queen or 2 full beds), 1st floor Harbor (2 full beds), 2nd floor Poolside (1 queen or 2 full beds), and 2nd floor Harbor (2 full beds).
Can I book an event here?
The hotel has indoor and outdoor event spaces, including a meeting room and a patio area with capacity for up to 90 guests. Catering and concierge services are available.
How far is the hotel from Long Island Mac Arthur Airport?
The hotel is approximately 50 miles from Long Island Mac Arthur Airport.
Are there beaches nearby?
Beach parking passes are provided for Southampton Town Beaches, including Long Beach, Sagaponak Beach, and Flying Point Beach.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
The hotel offers 24-hour front desk service, and daily housekeeping is provided. Specific check-in/check-out times are not detailed.
Is the hotel suitable for families?
Yes, the hotel is suitable for families and offers amenities like private bathrooms and a swimming pool. Beach parking passes are also provided.