Faraway Sag Harbor is a hotel located on the harborfront in Sag Harbor. It provides accommodations in harbor lofts and garden retreats. The property features a pool and open-air dining with views. The hotel includes a spa, a fitness center, and an on-site restaurant. Guests also have access to amenities like bicycle rental and water sports facilities.
Should you book Faraway Sag Harbor?
Expect harborfront rooms and suites, a sun-dappled pool, and dining with coastal flavors.
Best for
- Harbor views
- Poolside lounging
- Spa treatments
- Access to Sag Harbor
Maybe not ideal for
- Rooms may be in lofts or garden areas
- On-site restaurant has specific hours
Harborfront location
Situated directly on the Sag Harbor waterfront, the hotel offers views of the harbor. Accommodations include harbor lofts and garden retreats, designed for easy days by the water.
Pool and dining
A sun-dappled swimming pool is available for guest use. Open-air dining is offered, complementing the coastal flavors and champagne selections at the on-site restaurant.
Spa and fitness
ONDA Beauty Residency provides a curated menu of spa treatments. A fitness center equipped with Technogym equipment is also available for guest workouts.
Room variety
Accommodations range from village rooms with garden patios to harbor-facing lofts with sweeping views. Options include king and double bed configurations, with some featuring sleeper sofas or multiple bedrooms.
Rooms & rates
What you'll enjoy
Gallery
Amenities & facilities
Most popular facilities
- Massage
- Beach
- Garden
- 24-hour front desk
- Fitness center
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Bicycle rental
- Restaurant
Great for your stay
- Parking
- Restaurant
- Pet friendly
- Free Wifi
- Free parking
- Fitness center
- Non-smoking rooms
- Family rooms
Bathroom
- Free toiletries
- Shower
Outdoors
- Outdoor fireplace
- Outdoor furniture
- Sun deck
- Terrace
- Garden
Activities
- Bicycle rental
- Live music/Performance
- Bike tours
- Beach
- Evening entertainment
- Water sports facilities on site
- Entertainment staff
- Cycling
Food & Drink
- Coffee house on site
- Fruit Additional charge
- Wine/Champagne Additional charge
- Kids' meals Additional charge
- Special diet meals (on request)
- Snack bar
- Breakfast in the room
- Bar
Location
31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States, Sag Harbor, New York
Faraway Sag Harbor is located in Sag Harbor, New York.
5 sights nearby; the nearest beach, Windmill Beach, is 0.3 mi away.
Things to do nearby
- Sag Harbor Whaling Museummuseum0.3 mi
- First Presbyterian Churchplace of worship0.4 mi
- Temple Adas Israelplace of worship0.6 mi
- Mashashimuet Parkpark0.8 mi
- Short Beachbeach1.2 mi
Straight-line distances from the property · data © OpenStreetMap contributors
What guests say
8.4 / 10 · Very good on Booking.com, from 109 guest reviews
Faraway Sag Harbor earns consistent praise for its charming design, walkable waterfront location, and comfortable beds, with several guests returning year after year. However, a recurring thread of dissatisfaction runs through the reviews around value for money — amenities and in-room features (showers, TV, lighting) are seen as falling short of the premium price point. Staffing gaps at the bar, pool, and front desk also temper an otherwise warm reception.
Reviews scoring 9–10: 15 · average 9.5
They wrote about: staff, location, breakfast
Reviews scoring 7–9: 12 · average 7.8
They wrote about: location, room, comfort
Reviews scoring 5–7: 1 · average 5
They wrote about: location, staff, room
Reviews scoring Under 5: 2 · average 1.5
They wrote about: room
No reviews in the selected score range.
Good to know
House rules
- Check-in
From 4:00 PM
Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card at check-in.
- Check-out
Until 11:00 AM
- Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Enter your stay dates and check the conditions of your selected option.
- Age restriction
The minimum age for check-in is 21
- Pets
Pets are allowed. Charges may apply.
Frequently asked questions
Are there family rooms?
Yes, family rooms are available. The Harbor Two Bedroom Suite with Loft can accommodate families or groups.
What parking is available?
Free private parking is available on site and does not require a reservation. Valet parking and street parking are also options.
Can I bring my pet?
Yes, the hotel is pet-friendly. Pet-friendly rooms are available.
Is there a spa?
Yes, ONDA Beauty Residency offers a curated menu of spa treatments, including facials and massages.
What activities can I do?
Guests can enjoy water sports facilities, bicycle rentals, and cycling. The hotel also offers live music and evening entertainment.
What is the check-in/check-out process?
The hotel offers private check-in/out, express check-in/out, and a 24-hour front desk. A tour desk is also available.