Pony Island Inn is located on Ocracoke Island, near the village edge and a short walk from Silver Lake Harbor, shops, and restaurants. This motel property offers clean, modern rooms and suites, some with kitchenettes. It is the closest resort property to Ocracoke's beaches. The inn is a supporter of the Outer Banks Forever Adopt a Pony program, with guests able to visit pony Luna at the Ocracoke Pony Pens.
Should you book Pony Island Inn?
A straightforward motel stay with a seasonal pool and convenient access to Ocracoke's attractions.
Best for
- Beach access
- Walkable village location
- Families
- Dog-friendly stays
Maybe not ideal for
- Limited on-site dining
- No indoor pool
Seasonal swimming pool
The inn features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and sun deck, providing a place to relax. Additional outdoor furniture is available in a picnic area.
Island location
Situated on Ocracoke Island, the motel is positioned at the edge of Ocracoke Village, offering proximity to the harbor, shops, and restaurants.
Room amenities
Rooms include air conditioning, private bathrooms, flat-screen TVs, refrigerators, microwaves, and tea/coffee makers. Daily housekeeping is provided.
Rooms & rates
Standard Double Room
400.0 m² · sleeps 3 · 2 full beds
Inner courtyard view · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
Queen Room with Pool View
400.0 m² · sleeps 3 · 2 queen beds
Pool view · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
Queen Room
400.0 m² · sleeps 1 · 1 queen bed
Inner courtyard view · Air conditioning · Attached bathroom · Flat-screen TV · Free Wifi
What you'll enjoy
Gallery
Amenities & facilities
Most popular facilities
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Non-smoking rooms
- Free parking
- Free Wifi
- Family rooms
- Tea/Coffee Maker in All Rooms
Great for your stay
- Parking
- Private bathroom
- Air conditioning
- Free Wifi
- Bath
- Free parking
- Non-smoking rooms
- Family rooms
Private bathroom
- Toilet paper
- Towels
- Bath or shower
- Toilet
- Free toiletries
- Hairdryer
- Bath
- Shower
Bedroom
- Linens
- Alarm clock
Outdoors
- Picnic area
- Outdoor furniture
- Sun deck
Kitchen
- Microwave
- Refrigerator
Location
785 Irvin Garrish Highway, Ocracoke, NC 27960, United States, Ocracoke, North Carolina
Pony Island Inn is located in Ocracoke, North Carolina.
5 sights nearby, the closest being Bella Fiore Gallery Studio at 400 ft; the nearest ferry pier, Ocracoke Terminal - Silver Lake, is 0.7 mi away.
Things to do nearby
- Bella Fiore Gallery Studiogallery400 ft
- Ocracoke Watermen's Exhibitmuseum0.5 mi
- Light Stationviewpoint0.5 mi
- HMT Bedfordshirehistoric site0.5 mi
- HMT Bedfordshire Crew 1942historic site0.5 mi
Straight-line distances from the property · data © OpenStreetMap contributors
What guests say
8.8 / 10 · Very good on Booking.com, from 438 guest reviews
Pony Island Inn earns consistently strong praise for its unbeatable Ocracoke Island location, spacious and well-kept rooms, and warm staff — with many guests returning year after year. The property is honest about its modest, family-owned character, and a small number of guests flagged minor operational issues such as late pool hours, a worn parking lot, and one housekeeping lapse. Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with the inn widely regarded as excellent value for the area.
Reviews scoring 9–10: 27 · average 9.6
They wrote about: room, cleanliness, location
Reviews scoring 7–9: 3 · average 8
They wrote about: location, room, comfort
No reviews in the selected score range.
Good to know
House rules
- Check-in
From 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM
Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card at check-in.
You need to let the property know what time you'll be arriving in advance.
- Check-out
Until 11:00 AM
- Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Enter your stay dates and check the conditions of your selected option.
- Age restriction
The minimum age for check-in is 21
- Pets
Pets are not allowed.
- Groups
When booking more than 2 rooms, different policies and additional fees may apply.
Frequently asked questions
Does Pony Island Inn offer breakfast?
Pony Island Restaurant, located on site, is open daily for breakfast during the season.
Is parking available?
Yes, Pony Island Inn offers free private parking for guests.
What kind of rooms are available?
Rooms include Standard Double Rooms, Queen Rooms, and various suites such as the Banker Pony Suite, Blackbeard’s Suite, Garrish Suite, Lighthouse Suite, Pilot Town Suite, and Springer’s Suite. A dog-friendly cottage is also available.
Are there any family rooms?
The property offers family rooms, and specific room types like the Standard Double Room sleep up to three guests.
Is there WiFi?
Yes, the inn provides free Wifi access for guests.
Can I rent bicycles?
Yes, bicycle rentals are available at an additional charge.
Is the hotel pet-friendly?
Yes, the Cottage is a dog-friendly accommodation option.