Opened in 1912, Island City House Hotel is Key West's oldest operating guest house. It comprises three historic buildings – The Island City House, The Arch House, and The Cigar House – reflecting Victorian, Caribbean, and tropical plantation styles. The hotel is situated in Old Town Key West, offering guests convenient access to the island's dining, shopping, and waterfront activities. It welcomes families, groups, and couples seeking a blend of historic character and essential amenities.
Should you book Island City House?
A stay in a historic building with Victorian-inspired decor, full kitchens in many suites, and a garden swimming pool.
Best for
- Historic charm seekers
- Families and groups
- Those wanting kitchens
- Walkable Old Town access
Maybe not ideal for
- Guests seeking modern hotel chains
- Those preferring resort-style facilities
Historic architecture
Composed of three distinct buildings—The Island City House, The Arch House, and The Cigar House—the hotel showcases Victorian, Caribbean, and tropical plantation design elements. It is part of the Key West Historic Marker Tour.
Garden swimming pool
The property features a lush garden setting with an inground swimming pool, providing a relaxed atmosphere. Sun loungers and outdoor furniture are available on the sun deck.
Full kitchens in suites
Many suites include full kitchens, making them suitable for longer stays or for guests who prefer to prepare their own meals. Kitchens are equipped with refrigerators, microwaves, and stovetops.
Old Town location
Located at 411 William Street in Old Town Key West, the hotel is within walking distance of the Key West sea port, Mallory Square, and numerous dining and shopping options.
Rooms & rates
Arch House Street Queen Studio
28.0 m² · 1 queen bed
Entire studio · Private kitchenette · Attached bathroom · Balcony · City view · Air conditioning
Deluxe Queen Suite
36.0 m² · Bedroom 1: 1 queen bed Living room: 1 sofa bed
Private kitchen · Attached bathroom · City view · Air conditioning · Flat-screen TV · Coffee machine
Cigar House King
45.0 m² · Bedroom 1: 1 king bed Living room: 1 sofa bed
Private kitchen · Attached bathroom · Balcony · Pool view · Pool with a view · Air conditioning
Arch House Two-Bedroom
46.0 m² · Bedroom 1: 1 queen bed Bedroom 2: 1 queen bed Living room: 1 sofa bed
Private kitchen · Attached bathroom · Balcony · City view · Air conditioning · Flat-screen TV
Island City House Two-Bedroom Suite
51.0 m² · Bedroom 1: 1 king bed Bedroom 2: 1 queen bed Living room: 1 sofa bed
Private kitchen · Attached bathroom · Balcony · City view · Air conditioning · Flat-screen TV
What you'll enjoy
Gallery
Amenities & facilities
Most popular facilities
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Non-smoking rooms
- Facilities for disabled guests
- Free Wifi
- Family rooms
- Daily housekeeping
- Terrace
- Tea/Coffee Maker in All Rooms
Great for your stay
- Private bathroom
- Air conditioning
- Bath
- Free Wifi
- Flat-screen TV
- Family rooms
- Non-smoking rooms
- Facilities for disabled guests
Bathroom
- Toilet paper
- Towels
- Bath or shower
- Private bathroom
- Toilet
- Free toiletries
- Hairdryer
- Bath
Bedroom
- Linens
- Wardrobe or closet
- Alarm clock
Outdoors
- Outdoor furniture
- Sun deck
- Terrace
- Garden
Kitchen
- Coffee machine
- Cleaning products
- Toaster
- Stovetop
- Kitchenware
- Microwave
- Refrigerator
Location
411 William Street, Downtown Key West, Key West, FL 33040, United States, Key West, Florida
Island City House is located in Key West, Florida.
5 sights nearby, the closest being Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden at 0.2 mi; the nearest ferry pier, Key West Bight Ferry Terminal, is 0.3 mi away.
Things to do nearby
- Nancy Forrester's Secret Gardenattraction0.2 mi
- Audubon House and Tropical Gardensmuseum0.4 mi
- Mel Fisher Maritime Museummuseum0.4 mi
- The Basilica of Saint Mary Star of the Seaplace of worship0.5 mi
- Key West Aquariumaquarium0.5 mi
Getting around
- Key West Bight Ferry Terminalferry pier0.3 mi
- Sunset Key Ferryferry pier0.5 mi
Straight-line distances from the property · data © OpenStreetMap contributors
What guests say
9 / 10 · Wonderful on Booking.com, from 766 guest reviews
Island City House earns overwhelmingly positive sentiment for its lush tropical grounds, sparkling pool, prime Old Town Key West location, and warm staff — with many guests returning year after year.
Reviews scoring 9–10: 28 · average 9.8
They wrote about: room, location, facilities
Reviews scoring 7–9: 2 · average 8
They wrote about: location, room, bathroom
No reviews in the selected score range.
Good to know
House rules
- Check-in
From 3:00 PM
Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card at check-in.
You need to let the property know what time you'll be arriving in advance.
- Check-out
Until 11:00 AM
- Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Enter your stay dates and check the conditions of your selected option.
- Age restriction
The minimum age for check-in is 21
- Pets
Pets are not allowed.
Frequently asked questions
What is the history of Island City House Hotel?
Established in 1912, Island City House Hotel is Key West's oldest operating guest house. It is a part of the Key West Historic Marker Tour and features three distinct historic buildings.
What are the room amenities?
All rooms are air-conditioned and feature en suite bathrooms, hardwood floors, and include amenities such as a flat-screen TV, coffee machine, and linens. Many rooms also offer a private kitchen or kitchenette and a seating area.
Does the hotel have a swimming pool?
Yes, the hotel has an outdoor inground swimming pool located in a lush garden setting. A sun deck with outdoor furniture is also available.
Can I hire a bicycle at the hotel?
Yes, bicycle hire is available at the hotel. There is an additional charge for this service.
What is nearby the hotel?
The hotel is located in Old Town Key West, within walking distance of the Key West sea port (2 minutes), Key West Aquarium (12 minutes), and Mallory Square (1 km). Several places of worship and galleries are also very close by.
Are there dining options nearby?
Several restaurants are within walking distance, including Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant (1-minute walk), Cuban Coffee Queen Waterfront (5-minute walk), and Thirsty Mermaid (5-minute walk).
What types of rooms are offered?
Room types include Queen Studios, Queen Suites, King Suites, and Two-Bedroom Suites, varying in size and bed configuration. Most suites feature a private kitchen.
Is Wi-Fi available?
Yes, free Wi-Fi is available at the hotel for guests.
Does the hotel offer massage services?
Yes, on-site massage is available in the hotel gardens, provided by Essera Spa. Treatments include Swedish, Deep Tissue, Hot Stone, and Shiatsu massage.